Leading ingredient distributor and supply chain expert ACI Group has warned supplement brands that consumer trust is not a given – it must be earned and upheld after an investigation revealed that some creatine gummies contained much lower levels of creatine than advertised.
The exposé, by personal trainer and popular YouTube personality James Smith, found that many products on the market were not supported by clinical trials and were engaged in ‘science-washing’ to make misleading claims about their creatine content.
Karsten Smet, CEO of ACI Group, described the findings as a major industry failure: “Ensuring that food products deliver the nutritional benefits they advertise is not just important – it is a fundamental responsibility for brands. The recent exposé by James Smith on creatine gummies highlights a concerning issue that underscores the importance of independent clinical trials, rigorous testing, and truthful nutritional claims in the food industry.
“Some companies are not just skipping proper research; they are misleading consumers by cherry-picking studies or making exaggerated promises without credible evidence. Regulatory bodies, such as the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), play a pivotal role in overseeing health claims on food labels. The FDA mandates that any health claim must be backed by significant scientific agreement to prevent consumers from being misled. However, this exposé proves that self-regulation is not working. This situation requires tighter enforcement, mandatory third-party testing, and updated regulations to protect consumers from misleading claims.”
Smet argued for a clear and urgent solution to the problem, involving businesses, regulators, and consumers working together to ensure full transparency and accountability. “Businesses must do better. They should only use ingredients backed by independent clinical trials and invest in their own research to validate their products’ claimed health benefits,” he says. “This is not just about protecting brand reputation – it’s about protecting public health.
“Consumers should also take a more active role – questioning claims, looking for third-party certifications, and demanding transparency. Misinformation thrives when people don’t challenge it.
“Regulators should step up enforcement to hold brands accountable. Stronger penalties for misleading claims would serve as a deterrent and ensure that brands prioritise scientific integrity over marketing spin.
“The alternative is stark; if trust is eroded, consumers may lose confidence not just in certain brands but also in the supplement industry. No one wins in that situation – but we can prevent it by taking decisive action now.”
ACI’s portfolio includes a number of science-backed ingredients for supplement, nutraceutical, and functional food applications. To learn more about its range of products, visit www.acigroup.biz.
Innovations in Food (& Beverage) Technology is a quarterly magazine distributed globally both in Print and Digital formats. www.innovationsfood.com. Twitter: @Innovfoodtech. Instagram: @innovationsinfoodtechnology. Linkedin: www.linkedin.com/in/terry-prior52
